Untying My Shoes

How to Think About Pain After a Run

11/11/20266 min read

There is a sweet feeling of accomplishment that comes when I enter my house after a run, whether I travelled a far distance or just went for a couple kilometres around my neighbourhood. Standing at the entrance of my place, I fish through my pocket for my key and walk inside. In the entrance area, there is a small bench that I sit on while I unlace my shoes. I’m sweaty and I’m catching my breath, and I even feel a little sore, but it’s not a bad sore; it’s a good sore. A sore that means I worked my body. A sore that feels invigorating, well-earned. A sore that, even though it can be a bit unpleasant, is something I don’t attribute with any permanent damage done to my body. This relationship with this soreness—how I think about it and relate to it—is truly one of my biggest accomplishments and is the only reason I am still able to run.

Before I learned about neuroplasticity, I spent most of my twenties unable to run. I deemed tightness and soreness during or after running as reflective of potential structural damage. This pain signal was, I believed at the time, telling me that something was wrong and I needed to stop and stretch ASAP. This was especially true for my left knee, the part of my body that caused me to not run for about 6 years.

But I now know not to take such sensations at face value. Because of that, when I get home after a run, I’m not in a rush to urgently roll out my yoga mat and start doing stretches. Now, this isn’t to say that I don’t do light stretching anymore, but I don’t do it thinking that I’m fixing my body. I do it because it’s nice to stretch and relax after a run. It’s an incredibly subtle shift, but it changes everything.

But how, you might ask, do you get the confidence to brush off such pain in your legs? Isn’t pain something that should be heeded? Isn’t it telling me that something is wrong?

To that, I need to admit that sometimes pain can be reflective of something that is wrong and needs to be looked at by a qualified medical professional. It would be incredibly irresponsible of me to say otherwise.

But pain, unfortunately, is not so straightforward. The traditional idea of pain is that it is alerting you about something potentially damaged or diseased, like it’s an objective observer reporting the facts to you. But, despite how much it can grab your attention, it’s not objective, and we have a growing amount of research that is suggesting that pain is, instead, a subjective experience, a way of our nervous system telling us what it thinks is going on, rather than what is actually going on (see my References page to learn more about these concepts). A big part of how pain will manifest in our body is actually influenced by our beliefs, namely what we believe the state our body is in.

For instance, in 2002, there was an article published in the New England Journal of Medicine called “A Controlled Trial of Arthroscopic Surgery for Osteoarthritis of the Knee” that studied the efficacy of knee surgery for people that had been diagnosed with, you guessed it, osteoarthritis of the knee (Mosely et al., 2002). In the study, they performed a couple different knee surgery procedures on subjects (arthroscopic lavage and arthroscopic débridement, which are different ways of removing debris surrounding an arthritic joint) and compared those to subjects who were told they received a procedure but actually had not received any procedure (i.e. a placebo). The study found that “the outcomes after arthroscopic lavage or arthroscopic débridement were no better than those after a placebo procedure” (Mosely et al, 2002, p. 81).

That’s pretty profound. People that believed they were operated on felt the same amount of relief as those who had actually been operated on. This is a great example of how simply having the belief that your body is okay can, in some instances, be enough to alleviate symptoms.

So, you might ask, isn’t this just the placebo effect? It is in a way (this is about participants that were in the placebo group, after all). But it might be helpful to think of this in the inverse, the opposite of the placebo, which is known as the nocebo effect. Like the placebo effect, the nocebo effect is about anticipation, but it’s specifically about anticipating a bad outcome (Ozanich, 2011, pp. 136-137). The bad outcome, in this case, is feeling knee pain, and this can potentially be caused by the negative anticipation that you have a damaged knee (in other words, thinking that you have a bad knee).

So lets quickly inventory of what the subjects of the study believed (I obviously am making some generalizations here, but if I may just for argument’s sake).

  • They believed that they had osteoarthritis of the knee.

  • They believed that some structural damage in their knees due to osteoarthritis was what was causing them pain.

  • They believed that doing a procedure to alleviate the structural damage due to osteoarthritis would help alleviate the pain.

The second belief, relating to what was causing the pain, is the biggest factor related to the nocebo effect. The belief that structural damage related to osteoarthritis can cause pain is an anticipation of a negative outcome.

The study had 180 participants, and 60 of them received the placebo treatment, where they were tricked into thinking they received a surgery but actually didn’t. And the researchers made a good show of it. In the research article, they describe that “after the knee was prepped and draped, three 1-cm incisions were made in the skin. The surgeon asked for all instruments and manipulated the knee as if arthroscopy were being performed. Saline was splashed to simulate the sounds of lavage. No instrument entered the portals for arthroscopy. The patient was kept in the operating room for the amount of time required for the débridement. Patients spent the night after the procedure in the hospital and were cared for by nurses who were unaware of the treatment-group assignment” (Mosely et al., 2002, p. 82).

The word placebo is used for this group, but it’s not just about anticipating a good outcome because you think something is fixed after a fake surgery. It’s also important to note that the belief that something bad is going to happen (i.e. the nocebo effect) is disappearing. I realize that what I’m saying probably seems incredibly obvious, and you can say that placebo and nocebo are two sides of the same coin (and they are), but I think the removal of a nocebo is an incredibly important point to emphasize here. Because that, at the end of day, is what this whole neuroplastic pain is all about.

After spending time learning about these sorts of studies, I know that my perceptions of my pain can be a big game changer in how my pain manifests in my body. This calm, confident attitude is what I try to bring to my life and especially to my soreness after a run. Sure, there is soreness, and maybe you would even refer to that soreness as pain, but how am I interpreting it? And this is important because, as this research paper has suggested, that interpretation is not a neutral observation. If I think that something is damaged, that can affect how the pain will manifest. If I think something is not damaged, that can also affect how the pain will manifest.

The old Taylor would think: “oh man, running really tightened up my muscles and maybe damaged my bones, so I have to stretch things out to ensure that my pain doesn’t get worse throughout the day”. This is classic nocebo effect.

The new Taylor now thinks: “running strengthens my bones and tight muscles aren’t bad. I’ll do some light stretches, but if I don’t get to it right now, it’s no big deal”.

See how the self-talk has shifted? Both are coloured by emotion, with the first being driven by fear and anxiety, while the second is driven by calm and confidence. The second one, it’s probably no surprise, makes my post-run routine so much more pleasant, delightful even. I can slowly bask in the accomplishment of my run, enjoying the trickle of endorphins that sustain a subtle runner’s high while I have a shower and find something to snack on.

Does this mean I’m invincible? No, not at all. Did I change my outlook only after reading this one research paper? No, not even close. I have consumed so many books, research articles, interviews, studies, and other resources that have all contributed to my understanding and confidence. And all these resources acknowledge that there is a mechanism in my mind and nervous system that strongly responds to how I think about the sensations in my body. That’s something I can’t ignore anymore and building this understanding feels like a bigger accomplishment than any run I’ve ever been on.

Disclaimer

The information provided on this website is mainly for educational purposes and should not be used for diagnosing or treating a health condition, illness or disease, nor is it a substitute for professional care. If you suspect that you may have a medical or psychological issue, you should consult a health care provider in the field. This website provides advice on how to deal with neuroplastic chronic pain resulting from TMS through a mindbody perspective, and the content is not intended to serve as a substitute for drugs or other therapies.